Adam Leitman Bailey Articles

Adam Leitman Bailey Articles

An online resource of real estate law articles

  • Home
  • Real Estate Q & A

How to Handle City-Issued Violation Hearing, Apartment Law Insider

  • Condominium & Cooperative Representation

By Adam Leitman Bailey

If you get a city issued violation from certain city agencies, such as the Department of Buildings (DOB), the NYC Fire Department, or the NYC Department of Sanitation, and you want to fight it, you’ll need to appear at the Environmental Control Board (ECB) for a hearing. Here’s what you’ll need to know to prepare for the hearing.

city issued violation, Adam Leitman Bailey

Preparing for Hearing

Before the hearing date, you should collect certain information. The DOB’s Web site, www.nyc.gov/html/dob/html/violations/violations.shtml, has updated information about the ECB, including possible violation penalties and other useful information. You can also review the law governing the violation and read a discussion of the criteria needed to correct many of the most common violations.

The penalty guidelines give the administrative law judge (ALJ) discretion to order a mitigated (that is, reduced) penalty. Director/actor Woody Allen’s quip, “Seventy percent of success in life is showing up,” can be applied to fighting most city issued violations. By merely making an appearance and providing some reasonable excuse or defense, you may get the ALJ to impose the smallest or most reduced penalty, especially if you make a
decent case to support your position or can provide proof that you’ve corrected the alleged offense.

Winning the case requires proper preparation. In this age of information and technology, don’t rely solely on testimony to satisfy the decider of truth and justice. Almost every case should be presented with dated pictures or documentation proving the falsity of the alleged violation. This may include receipts, logs, reports, deeds, registrations, or other evidence. Also, witnesses to the conduct or lack of conduct leading to the violation should be prepared to be questioned.

Importance of Early Check-In

On the date of your ECB hearing, plan to arrive long before your scheduled hearing time. Assuming the government agency’s inspector or witness has also appeared for the hearing, cases are heard on a first-to-check-in, first-to-be-served basis. Litigants who arrive after 9 AM shouldn’t make any early lunch plans. Many days, only eight to 10 judges are available to hear well over 100 cases scheduled for hearings. Once you arrive, immediately complete a sign-in form and hand it to an official behind the sign-in desk to be date-stamped. Postponements are
freely given, but you must request them in person.

Parties Involved

Once your case is called and you enter the hearing room, you’ll be greeted by an ALJ, a representative from the city agency that discharged the city issued violation notice, and, in many cases, the inspector or person who issued the violation notice. Be forewarned: This won’t be a Law & Order courtroom. Instead, you’ll find yourself in a tiny room that looks like a small office and can’t accommodate more than four or five chairs, a desk, and a computer.

Your Hearing

Don’t let the lack of court decorum impede your efforts to seek justice for yourself or your client. The city agency has the duty to prove that you or your company committed the offense listed in the violation. So the agency gets the opportunity to present its case first. But you may request that the case be dismissed before testimony begins. If you believe that your violation was wrongly issued, you should ask for a dismissal based on a technical defense (discussed below) or other documentary evidence that clearly shows that the city issued violation was in error—for example, it named the wrong owner. Many times, the ALJ will listen to your argument but reserve his decision and proceed to hear the case.

The government agency may call a witness or witnesses to testify, or simply rely on documentary evidence, such as logs and photos, to prove its case. When the government finishes presenting a piece of evidence or questioning a witness, you’ll have an opportunity to question the evidence, try to discredit the witness, or ask the witness questions to get more information.

In one case handled by my firm a building inspector issued a violation notice for not properly maintaining a building in a safe condition, because of a metal railing pulling away from the wall on the sixth story of a residential building. After the government presented its case, the cross-examination of the witness revealed that the building inspector’s impaired vision made it impossible for him to have accurately assessed whether the building had been kept in such a dangerous condition. The inspector noted his need for a visual aid, such as glasses or contact lenses, to see properly. And he admitted that he was without any assistance on the date in question. The ALJ dismissed the case.

As noted above, in this age of video, Internet data, and photography, you should be prepared to win your case before you walk into the hearing room. After the agency has finished presenting its case and you’ve completed your cross-examination, you can present your own case. This can involve witnesses testifying or your presenting documents relevant to winning your case, including, but not limited to, photos, receipts, logs, deeds, or previous cases with similar facts that favor your case.

Keep in mind that ALJs rarely disagree with past decisions of their tribunal. So it’s wise to find previous decisions that demonstrate your argument at the hearing. Apartment Law Insider and its sister publication, Landlord v. Tenant, provide past ECB decisions.

The agency or judge will also have the opportunity to ask your witnesses questions and ask about the evidence that you provide at the hearing.

Common, Successful Defenses

Your due process rights under the U.S. Constitution provide one of the most common and successful technical defenses at an ECB hearing. The city agencies are required to take great precautions to ensure that you’re informed about a pending hearing. They must attempt service—that is, delivery—of the notice of violation personally to you or your company at your building. If unable to do so, they must stick or tape the notice to your building’s door. The city agency is then required to place a copy of the affidavit demonstrating service in the ECB hearing file. Additionally, if the agency can’t personally deliver the violation notice to you, it must mail a copy of the violation notice to all other addresses listed on any agency records, such as the Department of Finance or multiple dwelling registration. If any of these actions didn’t occur, you should demand that the case be dismissed.

Other common and successful defenses include the described offense not having the statute listed on the violation, the proper owner not being named on the violation, or the proper address not being listed on the violation. Cases involving an emergency condition resulting in a violation, and the inability to gain access to correct or repair a violation, have been dismissed in the past. Also, repairing a violation-causing condition while the ticket was being written has helped get violations dismissed.

Read more about Adam Leitman Bailey

Tags: city issued violation, department of building, department of sanitation, ECB, Environmental Control Board, hearing, hearing preparation, violation, violation notice

ARTICLES BY TOPIC

  • Appellate Litigation
  • Buyouts and Sale of Apartment Lease
  • Commercial Landlord Representation
  • Commercial Leasing Services
  • Commercial Tenant Representation
  • Condominium & Cooperative Board & Building Representation
  • Condominium & Cooperative Litigation
  • Condominium & Cooperative Owner & Shareholder Representation
  • Condominium & Cooperative Representation
  • Condominium/Board of Managers Representation of Newly Constructed Buildings & Conversions
  • Division of Housing and Community Renewal (DHCR)
  • Fire and Building Violations
  • Foreclosure Litigation Group
  • Homeowner and Tenant Associations
  • Insurance Defense Litigation
  • Landlord Representation
  • About Mitchell-Lama/ Housing Development Fund Corporation (HDFC) & Third Party Transfer Representation
  • Mortgage Finance Practice Group
  • Purchase & Sale of Homes
  • Purchase and Sale of Multi-Family Dwellings and Buildings
  • Real Estate Administrative Proceedings/Environmental Control Board
  • Real Estate Litigation
  • Tenant Representation
  • Q & A
  • Title Insurance Claims Group

RECENT POSTS

  • How To Run a Board Meeting
  • Adam Leitman Bailey, P.C. Settlement Negotiations Save NYC Owner Hundreds of Thousands of Dollars in Rent Overcharge Class Action Case
  • Adam Leitman Bailey, P.C. Achieves Favorable Settlement of Construction Defects Claims Against a Sponsor
  • Adam Leitman Bailey, P.C. Defeats Order to Show Cause Seeking to Stay Housing Court Eviction Proceeding
  • Adam Leitman Bailey, P.C. Revives Judgment Resulting in Clients Recovering Over $2.5 Million from Former Friend

TOP CONTRIBUTORS

Adam Leitman Bailey

Dov Treiman

John Desiderio
  • Popular
  • Comments
  • Tags
  • FDA’s Poison Prevention Packaging Rule: A Bitter Pill the FDA is Forced to Swallow
  • The New Rules of Seeking a Buyout of a Rent-Regulated Tenant
  • Rules Governing Anticipatory Repudiation of Contracts
  • New Rules of Substantial Rehabilitation to Remove Units from Rent Regulation Part II
  • Building Sold Before Violation Notice Issued
  • Public Health and Law : Assignment Essays | Assignment Essays: […] FDA’s Poison Prevention Packaging ...
  • Public Health and Law : Solution Essays - Solution Essays: […] FDA’s Poison Prevention Packaging ...
  • Who are the parties in the case and what are their respective interests? - Excelwriters: […] FDA’s Poison Prevention Packaging ...
  • Nutritional Health Alliance v. Food and Drug Administration - Longbeach Writers: […] FDA’s Poison Prevention Packaging ...
  • Public health and law | Law homework help – Hero Papers: […] FDA’s Poison Prevention Packaging ...
Adam Bailey Adam Leitman Adam Leitman Bailey apartment rent Appellate Division Case Co-op board member rights Co-op issues commercial landlord commercial lease commercial tenant condominium Condominium Board contract cooperative board court of appeals Dov Treiman eviction foreclosure Foreclosure law foreclosure litigation group Home purchase Insurance John Desiderio landlord Landlord and tenant landlord law Landlord Representation Lease Lease Provision License Agreement Mortgage nonprimary residence NY state law property owner property sale Real estate real estate litigation rent Rent stabilization rent stabilized RPAPL tenant law tenant rights violation notice

Read more from Adam Leitman Bailey

Huffington Post

The Cooperator

Apartment Law Insider

Commercial Observer

Adam Leitman Bailey, P.C.

Twitter Twitter

Follow @alb_pc on Twitter

Twitter Twitter

Follow @Aleitmanbailey on Twitter

LinkedIn

Adam Leitman Bailey on LinkedIn

Adam Leitman Bailey, P.C. on LinkedIn

Adam Leitman Bailey Articles © 2023. All Rights Reserved.

Powered by WordPress. Designed by Woo Themes