Adam Leitman Bailey Articles

Adam Leitman Bailey Articles

An online resource of real estate law articles

  • Home
  • Real Estate Q & A

Directors and Officers Insurance Does Not Cover Intentional Discrimination

  • About Mitchell-Lama/ Housing Development Fund Corporation (HDFC) & Third Party Transfer Representation, Adam Leitman Bailey, Condominium & Cooperative Board & Building Representation, Condominium & Cooperative Litigation, Condominium & Cooperative Owner & Shareholder Representation, Condominium & Cooperative Representation, Insurance Defense Litigation

By Adam Leitman Bailey & Colin E. Kaufman

In a recent decision that sent shivers of concern across New York co-op and condo boards, the state’s highest court held that the Business Judgment Rule does not protect individual condominium and cooperative board members against some personal liability. In response, real estate and insurance attorneys are reviewing directors and officers (D&O) policies and the law to try determine whether you’re protected in the event of a claim of discrimination. Here, two veteran attorneys explain the background and what some of your options may be.

April 26, 2013 — In New York, public policy is that you cannot be insured against intentional acts that bring about intended results, such punching someone, causing injury or purposely discriminating against a member of a protected class. One cannot profit from one’s own wrongdoing and thus, for example, the well-known prohibition against killing one’s spouse and collecting the life-insurance proceeds. Insurance companies cannot pay a judgment against an insured for punitive damages.

The fact that punitive damages are sought in a lawsuit will not prevent an insured board member from receiving a legal defense paid by the insurer. However, if both actual and punitive damages are awarded, indemnification applies only to the actual damages awarded and not to the punitive damages.

The Circular File

One area in which the public policy is clear is that of discrimination liability. Circular Letter No. 6 (1994) of the state Insurance Department (now the Department of Financial Services), which is binding on carriers for policies written in New York, states that liability insurance coverage for intentional wrongs is prohibited. And discrimination based upon disparate treatment is an intentional wrong whose resultant harm flows directly from the acts committed, so liability coverage for it is impermissible.

If a claim is made against an insured under a liability policy, there are two issues to consider: whether the insured has a right to indemnification from the carrier and whether the insured has a right to a defense paid for by the carrier.

As a practical matter, plaintiffs, including discrimination plaintiffs, nearly always allege (or seek to allege) facts or legal theories which bring the suit within coverage. If one of the claims is arguably within coverage, the carrier is obliged to defend.  Once the carrier is “at the table,” settlement is much more likely; carriers have cash with which to settle and little interest in vindicating the acts or procedures of their insureds.

Definitions and Exclusions

Every policy contains definitions which may limit coverage for certain events or persons and exclusions which except certain events from coverage. In a typical policy, the policy defines “Loss” in a manner which includes judgment and penalties only “if such violation is not knowing or willful,” and goes on to say that Loss does not include “matters uninsurable under the law pursuant to which this policy is issued.”

In the Exclusions section of a typical policy, the policy excludes from coverage at an act “based upon, arising out of or attributable to … any willful violation of any statute or regulation committed by such Insured.”

Insurance is governed by contract. Even if the insured thought he, she or it was covered, if the loss is outside the definition of coverage in the policy, there is no coverage. If the loss is one which has been excluded, again there is no coverage.

There is no good news in this article as far as coverage for board members who commit intentional torts and lose at trial as coverage will not be provided. Intentional discrimination cannot be covered as a matter of public policy, state law and departmental regulation.

Adam Leitman Bailey is the founding partner and Colin Kaufman is a partner at Adam Leitman Bailey, P.C

https://alblawfirm.com/articles/intentional-discrimination/

Read More About Adam Leitman Bailey

ARTICLES BY TOPIC

  • Appellate Litigation
  • Buyouts and Sale of Apartment Lease
  • Commercial Landlord Representation
  • Commercial Leasing Services
  • Commercial Tenant Representation
  • Condominium & Cooperative Board & Building Representation
  • Condominium & Cooperative Litigation
  • Condominium & Cooperative Owner & Shareholder Representation
  • Condominium & Cooperative Representation
  • Condominium/Board of Managers Representation of Newly Constructed Buildings & Conversions
  • Division of Housing and Community Renewal (DHCR)
  • Fire and Building Violations
  • Foreclosure Litigation Group
  • Homeowner and Tenant Associations
  • Insurance Defense Litigation
  • Landlord Representation
  • About Mitchell-Lama/ Housing Development Fund Corporation (HDFC) & Third Party Transfer Representation
  • Mortgage Finance Practice Group
  • Purchase & Sale of Homes
  • Purchase and Sale of Multi-Family Dwellings and Buildings
  • Real Estate Administrative Proceedings/Environmental Control Board
  • Real Estate Litigation
  • Tenant Representation
  • Q & A
  • Title Insurance Claims Group

RECENT POSTS

  • Adam Leitman Bailey, P.C. Defeats Summary Judgment by Long-Term Squatter Claiming Adverse Possession to Part of its Client’s Commercial Building
  • Escaping the Default Formula at the DHCR
  • Adam Leitman Bailey, P.C. Forces Cooperative to Approve Alteration Plans and Settles Discrimination Lawsuit
  • Adam Leitman Bailey, P.C. Secures Dismissal of Claims Against Individual Sponsor Principals in a Construction Defects Litigation
  • Adam Leitman Bailey, P.C. Successfully Defeats Former Co-Op Board President’s Attempt to Enjoin Certification of Board Election Results and to Require New Election

TOP CONTRIBUTORS

Adam Leitman Bailey

Dov Treiman

John Desiderio
  • Popular
  • Comments
  • Tags
  • FDA’s Poison Prevention Packaging Rule: A Bitter Pill the FDA is Forced to Swallow
  • The New Rules of Seeking a Buyout of a Rent-Regulated Tenant
  • Rules Governing Anticipatory Repudiation of Contracts
  • New Rules of Substantial Rehabilitation to Remove Units from Rent Regulation Part II
  • Building Sold Before Violation Notice Issued
  • Public Health and Law : Assignment Essays | Assignment Essays: […] FDA’s Poison Prevention Packaging ...
  • Public Health and Law : Solution Essays - Solution Essays: […] FDA’s Poison Prevention Packaging ...
  • Who are the parties in the case and what are their respective interests? - Excelwriters: […] FDA’s Poison Prevention Packaging ...
  • Nutritional Health Alliance v. Food and Drug Administration - Longbeach Writers: […] FDA’s Poison Prevention Packaging ...
  • Public health and law | Law homework help – Hero Papers: […] FDA’s Poison Prevention Packaging ...
Adam Leitman Bailey apartment rent Appellate Division Case Co-op board member rights Co-op issues commercial landlord commercial lease commercial tenant condominium Condominium & Cooperative Representation contract cooperative board court of appeals Dov Treiman foreclosure Foreclosure law foreclosure litigation group Home purchase Insurance Jeffrey Metz John Desiderio landlord Landlord and tenant landlord law Landlord Representation Lease Lease Provision License Agreement Mortgage New Construction Representation nonprimary residence NY state law property owner Purchase & Sale of Homes Real estate real estate litigation rent Rent stabilization rent stabilized Rosemary Liuzzo Mohamed RPAPL tenant law tenant rights violation notice

Read more from Adam Leitman Bailey

Huffington Post

The Cooperator

Apartment Law Insider

Commercial Observer

Adam Leitman Bailey, P.C.

Twitter Twitter

Follow @alb_pc on Twitter

Twitter Twitter

Follow @Aleitmanbailey on Twitter

LinkedIn

Adam Leitman Bailey on LinkedIn

Adam Leitman Bailey, P.C. on LinkedIn

Adam Leitman Bailey Articles © 2025. All Rights Reserved.

Powered by WordPress. Designed by Woo Themes